数据已迁移全部帖子与账号都已迁入新论坛,认领后即可继续你的老账号:立即认领账号 ↗前往新站
BGC桌游网 · 历史存档(只读)

BGC桌游网

本站为 BGC桌游网 历史存档,仅供浏览与回忆;登录与发帖已关闭,新讨论请前往新论坛。
BGC桌游网»全部版块 › 桌游主讨论区 › 桌面战棋专区 › Red Dragon Green Crescent
查看: 2,467|回复: 20
上一主题下一主题

Red Dragon Green Crescent

[历史存档]
1楼
发表于 2012-6-24 19:50:02|只看该作者
本帖最后由 lorricount 于 2012-6-24 19:52 编辑

We have played Red Dragon Green Crescent at HKSW Meeting on 23/6/2012.

Rough Major Wars and Events of our game:
North Korea unified South Korea in Turn 2
UK joins US side
Japan drop out of US Pack and become Neutral
Singapore joins US side
Europe refrains from entering War (i.e. French and Italy becomes neutral)
Australia become neutral
PRC Air War in Taiwan
PRC liberates Taiwan
US and China airwar in Taiwan Strait
China corporation blocks Panama Canal
Battle of Chinese Fleet and US Fleet at Taiwan Strait
Russia entered War to help China
Russia forces attacked US Fleet and sunk some carrier task forces
Vietnam joined the US side
Parkistan joined the US side
Major Middle East Engagement
China lost the game because unable to achieve victory conditions.

BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复
2楼
发表于 2012-6-24 20:19:49|只看该作者
求战报
BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复
3楼
发表于 2012-6-24 22:10:01|只看该作者
China corporation blocks Panama Canal——这一事件令人惊异
BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复
4楼
发表于 2012-6-24 23:02:37|只看该作者
绵羊中立可以理解 11区怎么会中立的?还不如投靠tg呢
tg又是怎么杀到巴拿马去的?
猴子投靠米帝就算了 巴铁这浓眉大眼的怎么也。。。白象在打酱油吗?
BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复
5楼
发表于 2012-6-25 00:25:06|只看该作者
据说还有更加惊悚和诡异的事件会发生。。。话说,都6月了还有人喝热咖啡么?
这个算子的裁切质量真是,太坑爹了。
BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复
6楼
发表于 2012-6-25 03:33:28|只看该作者
蝜蝂 发表于 2012-6-24 23:02
绵羊中立可以理解 11区怎么会中立的?还不如投靠tg呢
tg又是怎么杀到巴拿马去的?
猴子投靠米帝就算了 巴铁 ...


这棋看起来很不错啊,希望能有详细战报
BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复
7楼
发表于 2012-6-25 06:40:55|只看该作者
假人的幸福 发表于 2012-6-25 00:25
据说还有更加惊悚和诡异的事件会发生。。。话说,都6月了还有人喝热咖啡么?
这个算子的裁切质量真是,太坑 ...


人家用剪刀的
BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复
8楼
发表于 2012-6-25 07:53:55|只看该作者
壮哉我大中华
BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复
9楼
发表于 2012-6-25 08:28:29|只看该作者
Review of the game written by my opponent after playing with me:

http://www.boardgamegeek.com/thread/819589/f2f-game-of-the-combined-2-map-game-of-red-dragong

Just played another game of Red Dragon/Green Crescent face-to-face, this time we played the combined scenario... I am afraid that the combined 2 mapper game wasn't as great an experience as the single mapper Red Dragon scenario (which is tried and true). BUT, the situation is probably salvagable with a variant or two (those officially published with the rules)... Intrigued? This is basically what happened:

If you refer to my previous post, a similar series of event occurred; Korea fell relatively quickly and a lucky roll took Japan out of the war early... but this time, unlike in my previous game, Taiwan didn't fall nearly as readily.... the reason is because, during THE WHOLE GAME, all of the countries on the left map never got activated for war. So Iran never attacked the Arabs and Pakistan and India never went at it. There was only some minor pointless actions in the Southern Indian Ocean, nothing worth speaking of.... THIS MEANT that the US was able to use the left map's OP action for reinforcements and these were placed on the right map's holding box and then the right map's OP action was free to do whatever it wanted.... So basically it was the same game as JUST Red Dragon (without Green Crescent) but the game was totally unbalanced because the US was able to get reinforcements basically for free and made it nigh on impossible for the Chinese to win.

We reached turn 25 before the Chinese conceded because it was deduced that it was impossible for the Chinese to gain the remaining VPs for a victory. BUT the game ended twice in Chinese defeat well before this if we followed the letter of the rules:

1) the first time the game ended in a Chinese defeat because ALL the Chinese Units on the left map were destroyed (they have 1 to 4 surface groups on the left map to begin with, no where near enough to hold off the US, UK, France & Italy!!!)... yes, there were Iran units present but these were NEVER activated because the random event die roll just didn't happen. And in the rules it says if you are forced to do 2 "Pass" actions you lose... we thought that it was stupid in this situation so we ignored it, (this wouldn't be a problem if countries on the left map was actually activated for war!)

2) because the US had a TON of reinforcements in the right map, I think it was like 4 stealth fighters groups and 5 carrier groups!!! The only way the Chinese even stood a REMOTE chance (in hell) was to activate the Russian units, but the rules says that if you activate the Russians (beyond the 1st activation), you must roll a 1D6 and if you get a SIX, then the Chinese loses because you've just started a general war in the region by involving the Russians.... guess what... the 3rd activation of the Russian fleet, in an attempt to get them down to Taiwan and a SIX was rolled... GAME OVER... we ignored this to give the Chinese a chance and carried on though. Moving the Russians is a desperate move that the Chinese player would not have done if the US had to spread reinforcements on both maps... which it didn't because once again NO countries were at war on the left map!!

Summary: the way the game played out for us, it was TOTALLY UNBALANCED to the point of BROKEN!!! This was because NONE of the US fleet was needed on the left map and the Chinese didn't get ANY opportunities to gain any VPs from the left map (the VP requirement doubled in the combined game from 12 to 24VP). This was because NO country came into conflict on the left map because of the stupid random event table! It was like 1/54 chance or something similar for either Iran or India getting activated!!!

Likely FIXES for the problem: We've yet to try this but it is highly recommended that you start the game with Iran at war already AND/OR Pakistan/India conflict started (these are official variants)... OR may be a separate die roll to activate these countries for war..... how about: Turn 1, you must roll a 1 for both Iran/Arab axis and India (enters war on the US side) to activate each. Then on turn 2 you have to roll a 1-2 and on turn 3 you have to roll a 1-3 and so on.... so both countries will enter the war on turn 6.... The left map is supposes to be a simulation of the limited projection of Chinese naval power in the Indian Ocean and a burgeoning Indian Naval Power and an aggressive Iran in the Persian Gulf.... not much of a wargame if THERE IS NO CONFLICT!!!!

Another alternative is that the Reinforcement OP action on the left map Must result in the reinforcements placed on the left map NATO Holding box and NOT in the right map's holding box! (you can use house rule even if you start the game with Iran/India already at war as suggested above.) This could be a more elegant fix.. but will still be a problem if NO WAR starts on the left map because eventually the US player can move these reinforcements one area at a time to the right map! BUT at least there is time to reinforce the situation for the Chinese on the right map and its a risky move for the US IF Iran and or Pakistan enters the war on the Chinese side. (I still think the odds of an Iranian/Indian/Pakistan activation WAY TOO LOW even if you play it this way!)

A 3rd possible fix without changing to game too much is to have a VARIABLE VP requirement... the original 12 VP needed ONLY for the Chinese IF Iran/India/Pakistan/Arabs never enter the war and 24 VP if they do... Still... what is the point of setting up the left map if it RARELY is used in most games.. so I don't really like this fix.

There you've it... I wonder who play-tested this thing! A good potential of a game that fell flat again! Come on Decision!!! The only up side I can see is that at least this game is still salvageable... but still... as an end-product consumer, I don't want to feel like I am a BETA tester!
BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复
10楼
发表于 2012-6-25 08:30:25|只看该作者
Review by my opponent on a soltaire game played just before our game but it is on the Eastern Map scenario.

http://www.boardgamegeek.com/thread/818775/solo-game-of-the-red-dragon-rising-scenario

Just played a solo game of Red Dragon/Green Crescent for the 1st issue of Decision Games' Magazine Modern War, setting up the red dragon rising one map Asia scenario (which is essentially the same game that was publish in S&T 250 with some minor improvements and played on the same map.), game took about 1.25 hour, the Chinese won in 11 turns (out of a possible 30 turns), a very unlucky random event for the US on the first turn took Japan out of the war, isolating the few USN units around the Korean Peninsula. The Chinese then took advantage of its initial setup (setting up 2nd had quite a few advantages!) and invaded S.Korea and in about 3 turns, Korean War II came to an quick end with Kim smoking a Cuban cigar in Seoul (4VP) and to celebrate the Chinese managed to blow up 2 CVN in the Yellow Sea the next turn (4VP)! After some LR bombing of Taiwan to soften it up, the Chinese rebased all its air-force in Central China and then bomb the hell out of the units in Taiwan in the next few turns, sacrificing 70% of its whole air-force in the process and then the Chinese airborne took the Island (6VP), winning with 14 VP's. Ouch!!

For your information: For the US to win in this scenario, they need to hold out for 30 turns keeping China from getting 12 VPs. The Chinese will also lose if they roll a 6 on a D6 on any turn they activate the Russians (beyond the first activation). The Chinese will not be using the Russians unless things are pretty bleak.

Here is a picture of the end game, note the Chinese Airborne Units in Taiwan (since there are no Allied land units in Taiwan, the control of Taiwan goes to China, the remaining Allied Naval units stay where they are and the remaining Allied air units, if the game continued, will have to rebase elsewhere.) and a communist peace in a united Korea! Very Silly! No action occurred in the South, the Phillipines & Singapore entered the war on the US side, but since their units can't leave their immediate vicinity and China didn't invade down south, they made no difference to the game.






Excellent little game, Very fast playing, quick back and forward game, Definitely not 2nd Fleet! Very interesting situation with good narrative. The system really works surprisingly well and handles the grand strategic situation very well. I wouldn't call it an accurate simulation but it is fun. On top of it all there are a ton of variants and optional rules that you can explore! You can play in 3 eras which gives you slightly different units, there are even rules to use tactical nukes or even a preemptive nuclear strike (definitely a silly option for the losing side!). I for one really like the art work on the map.

Looking forward to playing the whole Red Dragon/Green Crescent 2 Mapper Campaign on Saturday F2F!
BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复
11楼
发表于 2012-6-25 08:33:18|只看该作者
本帖最后由 lorricount 于 2012-6-25 08:36 编辑

Play aids (by myself) for this game:

1. Major changes and special rules summary to assist player to advance from Red Dragon Rising to Red Dragon/Green Cresent (with Camp[iagn scenario and random event table).
2. Action Table for Chinese side (exclude very optional rules)
3. Action Table for U.S. side (exclude very optional rules)
Summary of Chinese Operations.pdf (125KB)
附件已存档,不可下载
Summary of US Operatons.pdf (121KB)
附件已存档,不可下载
Modern War issue no. 1 summ.pdf (81KB)
附件已存档,不可下载
BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复
12楼
发表于 2012-6-25 08:37:35|只看该作者
本帖最后由 lorricount 于 2012-6-25 08:39 编辑

16.20 Random Events for the Red Dragon Rising / Green Crescent Combined Campaign Game)

Note: Countries that either start the game allied with one side and which are subsequently out of the game due to either Random Event may not be brought back into the game later.

16.21 Random Event 1-1: Pakistan joins the war on the US side, unless India is already a US ally. If this event is rolled again, treat it as “no event.”

16.22 Random Event 1-2: The Philippines joins the war on the US side. Philippine units and bases are immediately available for full use according to all normal rules of play. If this event is rolled again, or if the Philippines had been earlier brought into play by other means, treat it as “no event.”

16.23 Random Event 1-3: The Gulf Arab states leave the war. Iran must be hostile for this to happen, otherwise ignore this event for the moment. If this event is rolled again, treat it as “no event.”

16.24 Random Event 1-4: The Suez Canal is sabotaged. Place the ‘Sabotage’ marker. US side naval units in the NATO Holding Box may no longer enter the game. Air and land units may still do so if eligible for rebasing (Op 16) or airlift (Op 7). If this event is rolled again, treat it as “no event.”

16.25 Random Event 1-5 / 1-6: Singapore joins the war on the US side. That nation’s units and its territory, including the base facility, are immediately available for full use according to all normal rules of play. If this event is rolled again, or if Singapore was earlier brought into play by other means, treat it as “no event.”

16.26 Random Event 2-1: A major Middle East War erupts. The Chinese player should roll a die: If that result is a six or more, the war has gone nuclear and the upshot is the game ends in a draw. Die roll modifier: If event “Iran in as PRC ally” has been rolled, add 1 to the die roll. Make a die roll check each time event 3-5 / 3-6 is rolled. Subsequent checks as mandated by this event are considered to mark a further expansion of the fighting across the Middle East. Meanwhile the Suez Canal is assumed blocked (see 16.24) and the game continues.

16.27 Random Event 2-2: Vietnam enters the war on the US side. Vietnam is henceforth available for use as a US/Allied base area for naval vessels and aircraft (no ground units). Place all Vietnamese units in Vietnam. If this event is rolled again, treat it as “no event.”

16.28 Random Event 2-3: If Iran is a Chinese ally, it drops out of the war. Turn marker to ‘Iran Out’. Ignore if Iran has not yet become an ally. If this event is rolled again, treat it as “no event.”

16.29 Random Event 2-4: Myanmar drops out of the war. Remove all Myanmar forces. Chinese forces in Myanmar are placed back into Southern China.

16.30 Random Event 2-5 / 2-6 / 3-1: India enters the war on the US side. If this event is rolled prior to event 3-5 / 3-6 / 4-1 bringing Iran in, and there is currently no Middle East War, The US player receives 1 x Indian CVL and 1 x Indian SAG at Singapore or in the Malacca Straits (See 7.18 for Indian movement restrictions). If Random Event 3-5 / 3-6 / 4-1 bringing Iran into the war is subsequently rolled, remove these Indian forces from play.

16.31 Random Event 3-2: Moslems in Sinkiang revolt against PRC. The Chinese player should roll a die, halve that result and round up any remainder. That number (one, two or three) is the total of Chinese ground and/or air units he must immediately and permanently remove from the map. (He picks them deliberately.) The removed units must generally be chosen from one or more of the three areas of the Chinese mainland. If, and only if, there are insufficient units on the Chinese mainland to meet the die roll requirement for withdrawal, he must then make up the difference by similarly choosing other Chinese units from elsewhere on the map. If this event is rolled again, treat it as “no event.”

16.32 Random Event 3-3 / 3-4: Venezuela and Cuba enter the war on the Chinese side. The US player should roll a die, halve that number and round up any remainder. That’s the number of units (one, two or three) he must now blindly draw from his reinforcement pool (representing forces permanently sent to the Caribbean front.) If there are insufficient units remaining in the US reinforcement pool at this time, he must make up the difference by deliberately choosing the appropriate number of US units from those already on the map. If this event is rolled again, treat it as “no event.”

16.33 Random Event 3-5 / 3-6 / 4-1: Iran enters the war on the Chinese side. Flip the marker to ‘Iran In’ and immediately place the ‘Level 2’ marker in the Persian Gulf. Chinese units may not base in Iran nor may Chinese and Iranian units move during the same Op. If Iran is already a Chinese ally or if this event is rolled again, treat it as “no event.”

16.34 Random Event 4-2 / 4-3: The Chinese corporation running the Panama Canal blocks that critical transit route. PRC will score one victory point. If this event is rolled again, treat it as “no event.”

16.35 Random Event 4-4: Taiwan leaves the war. Remove all Taiwanese units from the map and award the Chinese player six VP. If this event is rolled again by either player, treat it as “no event.” Any US/Allied units that may be on Taiwan at this instant are immediately rebased to Guam & Saipan or the US/Allied Off-Map Bases Holding Box (US player’s choice on a unit-by-unit basis). That rebasing doesn’t cost the US player an Op. Surrendered Taiwan is subject to possible attack and/or reinvasion by US/Allied forces. If this event is rolled again, treat it as “no event.”

16.36 Random Event 4-5: Tibet revolts against the Chinese. No further land reinforcements may be sent by PRC to Myanmar by Op 3. If this event is rolled again, treat it as “no event.”

16.37 Random Event 4-6: Tensions rise in Europe. Ignore if event 6-1 has previously been rolled. Otherwise, concerned that the Russians may enter the war, the Europeans hold back on sending further reinforcements. The US may not execute an Op 9 to bring either France or Italy in. If the additional UK units have not yet arrived, they never do. Diego Garcia remains a US base. If this event is rolled again, treat it as “no event.”

16.38 Random Event 5-1 / 5-2 / 5-3 / 5-4: Whichever player rolled this event may conduct two Ops in a row. Don’t make another random events pre-check or check at the start of the second Op. This event may be rolled any number of times per game by either player. This twinned Op counts as only one Op for purposes of rule 4.1 and may be taken on either map at player’s choice.

16.39 Random Event 5-5 / 5-6: The government of the player who rolled this event is floating a ‘peace feeler’ at the UN. The effect of that is to prohibit the rolling player from choosing any kind of attack as his upcoming Op. This event may be rolled any number of times per game by either player.

16.40 Random Event 6-1: Russia drops out of the war. If Russia had previously been brought in the war by the Chinese player, immediately and permanently remove all those forces from the map. The Russian land area is out of play for the rest of the game; any Chinese units that may be there at this instant are immediately rebased to Northern China. That rebasing doesn’t cost the Chinese player an Op. If Russia wasn’t brought into the war prior to rolling this event, Russia is now no longer eligible to be brought into the war in any way. If this event is rolled again, treat it as “no event.”

16.41 Random Event 6-2: Japan drops out of the war. Immediately and permanently remove all that nation’s forces from the map. All four Japanese islands (Okinawa, Honshu, Kyushu and Shikoku) are out of play for both sides for the rest of the game; any US/Allied units that may be in those areas at this instant are immediately rebased to friendly-controlled Guam & Saipan or the off-map holding box (US player’s choice on unit-by-unit basis). That rebasing doesn’t cost the US player an Op. If any Chinese ground units are on Okinawa, immediately rebase them to Northern or Central China (that player’s choice). If the Chinese player had earlier gained a VP for securing uncontested control of Okinawa, he keeps that point through the end of the game. All Japanese units and territory are permanently and fully out of play for both sides for the rest of the game. If this event is rolled again, treat it as “no event.” Also see rule 7.12.

16.42 Random Event 6-3: Australia drops out of the war. Immediately and permanently remove all that nation’s forces from the map. If this event is rolled again, treat it as “no event.”

16.43 Random Event 6-4: The US has successfully executed a “Special Action” raid. That player should immediately examine the map and then eliminate any one Chinese air or naval unit from anywhere on it. If the Chinese player had begun a ground war on the Korean peninsula prior to this, and that war is still going on, the US player may choose to eliminate one North Korean unit instead. If the Chinese player had earlier brought Russia into the war, and event 6-1 hasn’t been rolled, the US player may choose to eliminate one Russian air or naval unit instead. This event may be rolled any number of times per game.

16.44 Random Event 6-5: Successful US “Rods From God” strike. The US has successfully executed a strike with some kind of new weapon. That player should immediately examine the map and permanently eliminate any one enemy unit of any type—including ground units—from anywhere on it. The same restrictions apply as given above in 16.43, though, in regard to his ability to choose a North Korean or Russian target unit in place of a Chinese unit. If the elimination of a unit results in the total elimination of the Chinese garrison force on some previously invaded and conquered land area, the Chinese player keeps the VP he earned there until such time as one or more US/Allied grounds units is sent to actually reclaim the place. This event may be rolled any number of times per game.

16.45 Random Event 6-6: The Chinese have successfully executed a “Special Action” raid. That player should immediately examine the map and permanently eliminate any one US or Allied air or naval unit. Neutral units and units in the US/Allied Off-Map Bases Holding Box may not be chosen by the Chinese player. This event may be rolled any number of times per game.

BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复
13楼
发表于 2012-6-25 10:00:15|只看该作者
目测有的随机事件不科学{:soso_e113:}
BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复
14楼
发表于 2012-6-25 10:38:16|只看该作者
还是和第一版那样,中国去打巴拿马、北部湾到了胡志明市门口、世界陆军第三强国又没有陆军
BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复
15楼
发表于 2012-6-25 15:02:59|只看该作者
蛮爽的么~
BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复
16楼
发表于 2012-6-25 21:22:51|只看该作者
zhqcmd 发表于 2012-6-25 06:40
人家用剪刀的


我的意思是出版商裁切的质量,不是玩家裁切的。这个算子间裁切的缝隙太大了,修角都难啊。
BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复
17楼
发表于 2012-6-25 21:46:17|只看该作者
My opponent have bought two copies of this game. One for collection, the other one for playing, he just punched the counters without using any scissors.
BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复
18楼
发表于 2012-6-26 13:09:17|只看该作者
很期待Bruce Costello的新遊戲!
BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复
19楼
发表于 2012-6-29 21:42:40|只看该作者
本帖最后由 lorricount 于 2012-6-29 21:48 编辑

Photos of counters
BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复
20楼
发表于 2012-7-1 09:34:14|只看该作者
本帖最后由 lorricount 于 2012-7-1 09:36 编辑

Counters in high resolution.
BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复

全部版块|BGC桌游网

历史存档数据冻结于 2026-09 · GMT+8, 2026-11-21 13:33