数据已迁移全部帖子与账号都已迁入新论坛,认领后即可继续你的老账号:立即认领账号 ↗前往新站
BGC桌游网 · 历史存档(只读)

BGC桌游网

本站为 BGC桌游网 历史存档,仅供浏览与回忆;登录与发帖已关闭,新讨论请前往新论坛。
BGC桌游网»全部版块 › 桌游主讨论区 › 讨论 › (更新完毕)和FFG的邮件交流:关于魔龙扩规则的疑问
查看: 1,441|回复: 13
上一主题下一主题

(更新完毕)和FFG的邮件交流:关于魔龙扩规则的疑问

[历史存档]
1楼
发表于 2013-4-10 11:50:36|只看该作者
本帖最后由 rrssttrst 于 2013-4-11 10:08 编辑

这个贴,放在这里,而不是冰火版图专区里,是为了让更多人看到,解惑更多。

最近准备开魔龙扩,在翻BGC和BGG的过程中,发现很多武将相互作用的疑问,尚没得到很好的官方解答。

为了扫平开局的障碍。我给Jason Walden(Game Producer of Fantasy Flight Games)写了邮件,详细询问了一部分大家经常问的问题。

以下是已经确定结论的问题的FAQ。在官方FAQ出来之前,大家先看看吧。

也希望大家跟帖说出自己的疑问,大家共同讨论出结果:

首先,关于魔龙的FAQ,我问
hi

Would you provide a specific FAQ to cover main vague issues in this expansion, especially many interactive functions in house cards?

Many questions are frequently asked in BGG but answers are hard to be acquired officially.

Thanks a million!



他说:
We are working on an updated FAQ but are not ready to release it yet.
In the meantime, feel free to ask me any questions you may have and I'll be glad to answer them.



以下是我总结提出的一些已经确定的武将互动问题

question1:
if I use Doran for one battle and when I reveal this card, whether or not this card should be seen as still “in my hand”, since this will change the result in the combat strength calculation phase?
For example, if before the battle I have 6 house cards (including Doran) in hand and 1 discard one, and in the battle I choose to play Doran, then should the battle strength of Doran at this time be 6 or 5?



As he is being played, he is no longer considered "in your hand", nor your discard pile. Thus, in your example, his strength would be 0 (subtracting 5 for the five cards still in hand, but to no less than 0).



Question 3:
This is similar to question 1 but comes from Quentyn Martell. If before the battle I have 6 house cards (including Quentyn) in hand and 1 discard one, and in the battle I choose to play Quentyn, then should the battle strength of Quentyn be 2 (1+1) or 3 (1+2)?
That is, whether the revelation of Quentyn makes it a discard card at once which will increase the number of discard cards by one?



As he is being played, Quentyn is not considered "in your discard pile", nor your hand. Like Doran, he's in a space in between the two locations. Similar to the "moribund" state in A Game of Thrones: The Card Game (if you've ever played that). If you follow the order of Combat in the rulebook, you'll notice on page 21 under the Combat Clean Up step (the very last step of combat) it states "Both played House cards are discarded to their respective player's discard piles…"


Question 4:
Margaery Tyrell: if all the requirements of her ability are fulfilled properly, will the final battle strength of her opponent be 2, even the original final battle strength of her opponent is only 1?



That is correct. That is probably the one instance you wouldn't want to play her.



Question 5:
When Margaery Tyrell faces Mance Rayder, suppose the requirements of Margaery Tyrell ‘s ability are fulfilled properly, how I determine the final battle strength of Mance Rayder?



As stated on page 19 of the rulebook, all timing conflicts in regards to House card text abilities are resolved in the order of the Iron Throne track ("turn order"). The player in the higher position of that track (closer to the top) resolves his effect first, followed by the player lower on the track.

So in this case, let's assume that Baratheon is higher on the Iron Throne track. He would resolve Mance's card text ability first, making his final combat strength equal to the Wildling track. Then, the Tyrell player would resolve Margaery's card text ability, overriding the Baratheon player's previous strength entirely and making it equal 2.


Question 6:
When Doran Martell faces Margaery Tyrell, suppose the requirements of Margaery Tyrell ‘s ability are fulfilled properly, how I determine the final battle strength of Doran Martell?



Same as stated above in Question 5, the player on the higher position of the Iron Throne track would read and resolve their text ability first. Then, the next player would resolve his text ability, possibly overriding the previous player's resolution.


Moreover, in this confrontation, whether the sword symbol and stronghold symbol of Doran should be changed as indicated by his ability as usual? That is, does Margaery Tyrell’s ability change the way that Doran changes his own sword symbol and stronghold symbol?



Margaery's ability does not in any way have any effect on Doran's sword and fortification icon ability. He would receive those icons regardless of his final combat strength.


Question 7:
The activation of Melisandre’s ability is optional, not compulsory, right?



Yes. Melisandre's ability includes the word "may" which makes it entirely optional.


If I have Melisandre card and it is my last house card unused, after I use it for a battle and I choose to activate her ability to get Mance Rayder back in hand, at this moment, does the card reshuffle mechanism activate? (which I think will put Melisandre in discard and will take all other cards back in hand), or the Melisandre’s ability activates rather than the card reshuffle mechanism?( which I think will first put Mance Rayder back in hand, and will then discard Melisandre and will not activate card reshuffle mechanism since now Mance Rayder is still in my hand)



The timing on this one is understandably a little bit tricky. But try to follow the rules as literally as possible to determine the outcome. I've attached the most recent FAQ from the base game to help with the timing.

As stated in the FAQ, cards with the phrase "After combat…" take effect after the Combat Clean Up step. It is during this step that House cards are discarded to the discard pile and new cards are drawn back if the card played was the last card in hand. As such, if Melisandre was the last card played, her effect wouldn't be resolved until after the other cards in the discard pile were drawn back into hand. Thus, she could only choose herself to return to hand.


Question 8:
The Aeron Damp Hair card says that you can discard power tokens to equal the power that you want and that's easy to understand but when do you do that? Do you say how many you're committing before you see your opponents card?
According to the basic rule or the game, the text on cards is resolved in turn order after they are revealed is they have no “immediately”, “cancel” or “ignore”. But the high turn order will bring disadvantages if two cards with bidding ability fight each other, since the player who bids second will know exactly how much he will pay to win the player who bids first.
For example, Aeron VS Qyburn
I think high turn order should bring advantages but here it seems not, is this reasonable?



As stated above, the players resolve conflicts like these in turn order of the Iron Throne track. For some effects, it is beneficial to go first. For others, it is beneficial to go last. In this case, it just so happens to benefit the player in the lower position. That is perfectly acceptable and intended.

BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复
2楼
发表于 2013-4-10 11:51:11|只看该作者
本帖最后由 rrssttrst 于 2013-4-11 10:11 编辑

今天更新3个FAQ,我的现有问题完毕了
特别注意第10个问题,这个问题的解答,好像和中文卡牌上的文字描述意思相差较远。。。


Question 9:
Probably I do not make myself understood and I try to restate my confusion in Question 2 again.
If before the battle I have 6 house cards (including Doran Martell) in hand and 1 discard one, and in the battle I choose to play Doran, then at this point should I count Doran as one with 0 combat strength and 5 sword symbols plus 5 fortification symbols?
My confusion about this comes up when my friend tells me that he thinks because Doran’s combat strength decreases by 4 to 0 in this occasion, the increment of his sword symbol and fortification symbol should equal to the decrement of his combat strength, which makes them to be both 4, rather than 5 (5 house cards in hand).
Which one is right? 0 plus 4+4, or 0 plus 5+5?






Ohhh, I see the issue now. Thanks for clarifying. Sorry for the confusion on my part.

The addition of sword and fort icons to Doran's card are irrelevant to his combat strength. You could almost consider those to be two separate abilities:
1) He gains +1 sword and +1 fort for each card still in your hand.
2) He suffers -1 combat strength for each card still in your hand (to a minimum of 0).


Question10:
This is about the reader, Greyjoy. This card’s ability, I think, acts like this: after you win a battle, you choose one deck of westeros cards and pick one card from all cards of this deck (including the ones used as well as those unused), then reshuffle the ones used as well as those unused together to form a new deck and put that one on the top.
Because I saw some players from BGG states:
The deck consists of cards that have not yet been used. Those that have been used are considered in the "discard pile".
The Greyjoy player would be able to look at only the cards that haven't yet been used.
Just the remaining cards would be shuffled afterwards, not the discard pile.

So I wonder which opinion is correct,mine or the BGGer’s one listed above?



The other BGGer is correct. In fact, I think he may be quoting my answer to him directly (I've answered this question in other emails as well).

The key is in differentiating the difference between the "deck" and the "discard pile". The Reader can search any deck, which does not include the corresponding discard pile. The "remaining cards" then refers to the other cards in that deck not chosen, which also does not include the corresponding discard pile.


Question 11:
If you play Ser Gerris Drinkwater;

"If you win this combat, you may move one position higher on one Influence track of your choice."
And in doing you end up on the top of the fiefdom track. You would then take the Valariyn Steel Blade.

My Question is:
If the blade has been used already in this round would you acquire it in it's used state or would you be able to use it that round?




It would be acquired in its used state. It flips back over at the end of every Action Phase, regardless who is the holder.

BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复
3楼
发表于 2013-4-10 14:30:00|只看该作者
非常感谢分享!
BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复
4楼
发表于 2013-4-10 14:35:44|只看该作者
本帖最后由 gjghost 于 2013-4-10 14:39 编辑

我也把另一个帖子中问 游人码头的问题汇集到这吧。。

1. 瓦德•佛雷如果支援对方的是对方自己的军队,应该不必改为支援史塔克吧?
瓦德•佛雷技能:所有支援对方的其他玩家,必须改为支援你。

1. 是的。卡牌规则描述得很清楚了“支援对方的其他玩家”。

2. 荆棘女王对上任何人,都是以她的技能为先?无视对方的卡牌文字?
荆棘女王技能:所有支援对方的其他玩家,必须改为支援你。
2. 是的。基础规则P19,有提到家族卡牌的结算顺序,“忽略”排在第一位。
3. 道朗•马泰尔最后一句“战力最小减到0”?如何解释?
举个例子,我手牌有6张,那么我可以把战力减到-2,然后算作0,获得6剑6堡,还是只能减到0,获得4剑4堡
道朗•马泰尔技能:你的手牌中每有一张家族卡牌,本卡牌获得一个铁堡符号和一个利剑符号,并获得战力-1(最小到0)。
3. 6剑6堡,0战力。

4. 玛格丽•提利尔 vs 曼斯•雷德, 谁的技能优先级高?后者始终是2?
玛格丽•提利尔 vs 道朗•马泰尔, 即使后者发动技能把自己战力降到0,获得4个剑4个堡,还是视作后者战力为2?
玛格丽•提利尔的技能是强制发动还是玩家可选?(注意到技能描述没有 “可以”或者“必须”关键字)
玛格丽•提利尔技能 :如果你作为守方,并且在交战区为你的主城或有你的权力标记,对方总战力等于2。
曼斯•雷德技能:你的总战力等于野人威胁标记的当前位置。

4. 待确认。个人偏向于等于2。

5. 史坦尼斯•拜拉席恩如果要发动技能,必须在战斗结算第一步,不接受任何支援(包括自己)?
史坦尼斯•拜拉席恩技能:如果你在本次战斗中没有被支援,从交战区域的相邻区域移除所有(包括你的)支援指令标记,取消这些指令提供的支援战力。

5. 是的。如果你接受支援了,之后的能力就没有了

6. 关于Setup的:规则说可以用现有的家族牌代替原有的,那么是否这是开局是玩家自己决定?还是说会出现某几个玩家选了旧将,某几个选了新将?
根据说明,可以基础版游戏时用扩展家族卡牌,扩展剧情还是要使用扩展家族卡牌。并且使用时,是需要42张家族卡牌全部更换,保持一个版本之下。当然这个还是根据玩家们之间自己的喜好进行游戏。
BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复
5楼
发表于 2013-4-10 14:45:44|只看该作者
本帖最后由 gjghost 于 2013-4-10 14:59 编辑

看来我的第四问 呵呵了。

BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复
6楼
发表于 2013-4-10 14:55:03|只看该作者
mark~突然想重拾好久不玩的冰火
BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复
7楼
发表于 2013-4-10 16:42:31|只看该作者
gjghost 发表于 2013-4-10 14:45
看来我的第四问 呵呵了。


你的第四个问题,walden的解释是,谁王位排序在后面,谁占优势

此外,你的第三问,其实是我的第二问(没在这里贴出),但是walden好像没听懂我的问题叙述,所以这个问题的答案我还在继续确认
BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复
8楼
发表于 2013-4-10 17:04:57|只看该作者
rrssttrst 发表于 2013-4-10 16:42
你的第四个问题,walden的解释是,谁王位排序在后面,谁占优势

此外,你的第三问,其实是我的第二问(没 ...

我也觉得应该按照铁王座顺位排序。。。不过排在后面的技能覆盖前面的,让我觉得有点不合理,我总觉得应该是排前面的覆盖后面的,虽然他说了(后发动的不一定有优势)
BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复
9楼
发表于 2013-4-10 17:30:39|只看该作者
dddxxx88 发表于 2013-4-10 14:55
mark~突然想重拾好久不玩的冰火


我也是在重拾中{:3_76:}
BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复
10楼
发表于 2013-4-10 23:54:20|只看该作者
gjghost 发表于 2013-4-10 17:04
我也觉得应该按照铁王座顺位排序。。。不过排在后面的技能覆盖前面的,让我觉得有点不合理,我总觉得应该 ...


doran描述中所说的 “手中的牌”,不包括doran本身这张打出的牌,他给我解释的意思是说,reveal这个瞬间,doran这张牌的状态既不是in hand 也不是discard。

成为discard,要到战斗结束前的最后时刻,也就是,在其他武将卡牌描述的“战斗结束后”这个时间点之前。
BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复
11楼
发表于 2013-4-11 09:49:50|只看该作者
rrssttrst 发表于 2013-4-10 23:54
doran描述中所说的 “手中的牌”,不包括doran本身这张打出的牌,他给我解释的意思是说,reveal这个瞬间 ...


这点我其实是同意的。。 打出的状态,大家都reveal的时候不算弃掉,只有在清理战场阶段才弃掉。
BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复
12楼
发表于 2013-4-11 10:13:06|只看该作者
gjghost 发表于 2013-4-11 09:49
这点我其实是同意的。。 打出的状态,大家都reveal的时候不算弃掉,只有在清理战场阶段才弃掉。 ...


特别注意第10个问题的答案
BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复
13楼
发表于 2013-4-11 10:28:44|只看该作者
本帖最后由 gjghost 于 2013-4-11 10:41 编辑

rrssttrst 发表于 2013-4-11 10:13
特别注意第10个问题的答案

谢谢 更新,
关于greyjoy的那段,中文牌面是“如果你赢得本次战斗,你可以从任一维斯特洛卡牌堆中搜寻一张卡牌。重洗余下的卡牌并将所搜寻的卡牌面朝下放置到卡牌堆顶部。”

既然提到了重洗,所以我带的时候也没想那么多,直接忽略弃牌堆,从unused牌堆中search;当然这样做也是有好处的,其他人不知道你选了哪张,应为弃牌堆信息是明的吧。

第11问,好像faq里有说过,如果3大法器,回合内易主,如果已经翻面了,就只能下个回合再用了
BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复
14楼
发表于 2013-4-12 08:51:49|只看该作者
无脑顶一下,让更多人看到
BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复

全部版块|BGC桌游网

历史存档数据冻结于 2026-09 · GMT+8, 2026-11-20 12:59