数据已迁移全部帖子与账号都已迁入新论坛,认领后即可继续你的老账号:立即认领账号 ↗前往新站
BGC桌游网 · 历史存档(只读)

BGC桌游网

本站为 BGC桌游网 历史存档,仅供浏览与回忆;登录与发帖已关闭,新讨论请前往新论坛。
BGC桌游网»全部版块 › 桌游主讨论区 › 游人游语 › 【译】【电力工厂】一些简要的电力工厂策略心得
查看: 5,793|回复: 22
上一主题下一主题

【译】【电力工厂】一些简要的电力工厂策略心得

[历史存档]
1楼
发表于 2009-10-23 23:15:33|只看该作者
本帖最后由 bibby001 于 2009-10-23 23:23 编辑

作者:Alex Rockwell
翻译:Bibby

编者语:周日的2009华东桌游大聚会电厂比赛即将拉开帷幕,在此奉上一篇适合新手学习电厂策略的心得。

在玩了看了许多盘游戏之后的一些对电力公司的心得 首先,电厂发电能力最为关键,因为你的最后得分是取你发电能力和城市数量的较低值(假设你有足够的资源,如果你无法获得这些资源,那么发电厂的发电能力为0)。在游戏后期,提升你的城市数量往往比提升你的发电能力更容易。玩家往往提前建造完满足游戏结束条件的城市,而发电能力还未达到城市数量。 游戏趋向通过回合顺位机制惩罚那些在城市数量上领先的玩家,但是在一个很小的程度惩罚那些在发电能力上领先的玩家(有时候当城市数量相同时,由高位的发电厂决定顺位)。 那么我们如何获得高的发电能力呢?一旦他们出现就买下来。游戏往往经历4种情形:情形1,场上只有没什么价值的发电厂,你就将就用下原有的。情形2,第1个像样的高发电能力的发电厂出现了。5个及以上的发电能力的电厂最为重要。情形3,电厂拍卖枯竭,因为这些好电厂被拿走,而可拍卖的是那些剩下的没人要的低发电能力电厂,玩家就不拍卖了。如果你在发电能力上落后,你无论如何都追赶不上。在这一点上,如果你在城市数量上落后但是在发电能力上领先,你一般都能在城市数量上赶上,只要你在地图上一个合理的位置。情形4,当电厂拍卖再一次激烈起来,而你最后得到了真正有价值的电厂。此时,一般情况,所有玩家都能升级电厂,所以每个人都在提升发电能力。你在早期就建立起的发电能力的领先往往能够保持,除非这种情形持续超过2回合,使得其他玩家能够赶上。在发电能力领先的玩家在这种情况发生前会尽可能地尝试结束游戏。 了解所有这些情形,在情形2的时候得到至少一个高发电能力的电厂是非常紧急的。2个更加好。高发电能力是指5或以上。4也可以。5明确意味着这个电厂不会在后面被取代,除了在非常坏的情况下,没有相应的资源并且你没有库存。 经常地,这意味着煤或者石油电厂。3垃圾发6城(30号电厂)可以考虑,核能发4城(28号)以及2垃圾发4城(24号)也能用用。然而,煤和石油电厂在游戏结束前往往是获得高发电能力最好的选择。但这也会被游戏后期获取相应资源的难度所制衡。 游戏早中期,这些高发电能力的煤、石油或者混合电厂,像20、21、25、26、31、32,往往较之相同发电能力的电厂花费更少。当然,风能电厂虽然是免费发电,但是其较低的发电能力需要注意,可以作为不错的辅助电厂。 这一般意味着你需要至少1个中等发电能力,4或者5的煤、石油、混合发电厂。15和16号电厂,煤和石油发3城,在游戏早期也是不错的。 然后,你不能做得太过。把所有煤电厂都买下往往无法运作,就像昨晚我碰上的一局。我买了20,然后25,再买了31,结果后来太依赖煤,结束时被狠狠地挤压。 然而,如果你注意到煤或者石油的电厂很少出现,尤其玩家很快停止使用他们早期的煤或石油电厂,那么把仅有的2到3个中期出现的煤或石油电厂全部买下,并且成为唯一使用该种资源的玩家,会是一个不错的想法。如果那种资源在你这么做之前相当便宜,那么你可以非常高效地运作。但是,如果游戏出现了太多了这种资源的好电厂,你就得好好考虑要不要这么做了。 版图位置,同样重要,重要性往往仅次于发电能力。除非你版图发展能力相当差,或者某个玩家得到了一块非常大的区域抑或是其他状况,否则用正确的价格买下正确的电厂会有非常好的效果。 应该说,从版图上便宜的地方开始发展要好,哪怕存在更多的竞争。一件重要的事情需要注意,早期走便宜管道、后期走贵的管道比早期走贵的管道、后期走便宜的管道只有好一点点。你也许扩张地更快,并且在几回合里得到更多的钱,但是在最后你还是要付同样的钱建造城市。与你版图位置的好坏更相关的是,你第一个城市周围有多少相连接的城市,以及第二个、第三个(##)。在早期花费在10以上的管道费,以及游戏后期花费20以上的管道费去造第三座城市,都是不划算的。要么在早期,要么在晚期,你需要去获得那些便宜的城市、管道等。在2-3人游戏中,这不会是一个问题。但是有4+玩家,这很关键。因为三个玩家可以把你封锁在一块管道费相当便宜的地方之外。 下面考虑起始的电厂,对于每个编号的电厂都有优点和缺点。提供1个发电能力的电厂在第1回合给你少量的收入,但是你同时在电厂资源上也花费得少,并且你最先挑选资源。4号电厂非常好,在我看来,你可以在第1回合仅仅花费5块钱买4个煤,并且你一定会在第2回合第1个购买煤,所以你可以到那时买到2个相对便宜的煤。如果你在第2回合买了更大的煤电厂,像10,15,20,21(混合)或者25,那么你将可以买多于2个煤,相当地便宜,并且把4号电厂作为煤的仓库。接着你可以在城市数量上取得领先,通过使用你在之前购买的便宜的煤,来避免在玩家顺位比较糟糕的情况下购买高价煤。当你需要更多的煤,预先获得了额外的现金的你可以返回城市数量最少的顺位1回合。 3号电厂类似于4号,但是石油的价格更贵,起始为3。在第1回合买4个石油是相当痛苦的,并且把3号电厂当作是有仓库也不是那么需要。我不太喜欢3号电厂。 5号挺好,你很有可能第2个选择它(注:在拍卖阶段),购买相对便宜的煤,并且之后又更多的变化。 6号是烧一个垃圾,烧一个花费7块钱的垃圾。这个早期的电厂往往只被用几次,所以当你可以用烧2个便宜的石油或煤来替代它,你不会想花7块钱买个垃圾,去运营1个发电能力的电厂。总是有比6号更好的选择。(编者注:没有比6号更垃圾的垃圾电厂了) 7号是一个好电厂,3石油提供2个发电能力。它比3号差一点,但是至少3号不会用太久,不过7号也不会很久。你通过给另一个城市发电获得11块钱,但是你会支付9-13块在3个石油上,而不是2个煤4块钱,所以你多出来的收入实际也就是那么点。作为这些多出来的收入的代价,就是你会轮到较差的顺位,较差的电厂选择和较差的资源价格。 8号也不错,但是大概要比7号差点。一般情况下,4号和5号会被买走,然后买走5号的玩家会买走2个煤,所以你要购买3块/个的煤,就像7号要买石油那样。 然而如果3号不存在,那么8号要比7号好。多赚的钱的代价就是放置城市、购买资源上位置靠后,并且电厂拍卖靠前。 如果我要给这4个电厂排序,我会选择:#4,#7,#8,#5。但是4号和7号的差别还没大到我肯在4号上花比7号多很多的钱。 9号不错,只要1个石油提供1个发电能力,所以它大概只要4块钱就能运行。它会在早中期高效地运作,而3、4号不行。10号也不错,但是如果4号、5号和8号都买走了,你就会在煤的价格上吃紧。 我往往认为优先摆放城市的位置的好处要大于从2个发电能力上多赚的钱。当你先造城市,你应该先造在版图上相对便宜的区域,最好是那些没人能跟着你,偷着进入便宜区域的位置。在一个能够卡住一小块便宜区域的稍贵一点的区域发展也是非常不错的(那一小块区域不足以让一个人在里面发展)。另外,没人能够通过你,因为那太贵了(至少不能太近),然后你就可以随心所欲的取得哪些便宜的城市。 这样做的好处是在一些时候保证你能进入这些便宜区域。如果你不很早地拿下它们,而且其他玩家后来把你卡住,不让你进去,那样会很伤。这个在4+的游戏中更为重要。
BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复
2楼
发表于 2009-10-23 23:15:54|只看该作者
本帖最后由 bibby001 于 2009-10-23 23:18 编辑

原文地址:http://www.boardgamegeek.com/thread/22259
Some brief power grid strategy thoughts

Well, some thoughts on Powergrid after playing + watching a couple dozen games.


First of all, plant capacity is of high importance, because your final score is the minimum of your plant capacity and the number of cities you have (assuming you have resources for your plants...if you cant get teh resources, that plant is effectively 0 capacity). Late in the game it tends to be easier to increase your number of cities than to increase your plant capacity. Players tend to be able to reach the number of cities needed to end the game before they are able to reach the same number in plant capacity.


The game tends to punish those that are ahead in terms of number of cities, through the turn order mechanic, but it punishes those ahead in plant capacity to a much lesser extent (occasionally through the tiebreak for number of cities, determined by highest number plant).


So how do we get high plant capacity? Buy the high capacity plants when they appear. usually the game goes through 4 main parts:

Part 1, only crappy plants are available, you just make do.
Part 2, the first decent, higher capacity plants become available. Most important are the 5 or higher capacity plants.
Part 3, the plant auctions dry up, because these good plants are taken enough lower plants that are bad come up that people want none of the available choices and do not auction. Here, if you are behind in capacity, YOU CANT DO ANYTHING TO CATCH UP. If at this point you are behind in cities but ahead in capacity, you can generally catch up in number of cities, with a reasonable board position.
Part 4, is when the plant auctions finally start moving strong again, and you get to the realy good plants at the end. Here, generally all players are able to upgrade, so everyone is improving their capacity. A lead you had in capacity from earlier will tend to REMAIN, unless this phase goes on for more than 2 turns and the others catch up. The leader in plant capacity will attempt to end the game before this occurs.


Knowing all of that, it is critical to get at least one high capacity plant in the second of those 4 parts of the game (which should not be confused with the three formal stages of the game). 2 high cpaacity plants is even better if possible. High capacity generally means 5 or better. 4 is ok. 5 means it definitely wont have to be replaced later on, except in the very bad case that resources for it do not exist and you have no stockpiles.

Almost always, this means going for coal or oil plants. The garbage 6 cap plant (the 30) may come out, and the uranium 4 and garbage 4 plants (28 and 24 respectively) might work. However, the coal and oil plants tend to be the best way to get a high capacity, before the end of the game.
This is balanced by the late game difficuly of finding resources for them.

Early and in the midgame, these high capacity coal, oil or hybrid plants, like the 20, 21, 25, 26, 31 and 32, tend to cost less or and equivalent amount to run than their alternative energy peers (which are a bit lower capacity). Wind plants are of course free to run but have significantly lower capacity and are a good secondary plant.

This generally means that you will need to have at least one mid number, 4 to 5 capacity coal, oil or hybrid plant. The 15 and 16 (3 capacity coal and oil plants) are good in the early game as well.

However, you should not over do it. Buying all the coal plants tends not to work, as I found in a game last night. I bought the 20, then the 25, then the 31, and ended up being too dependant on coal and screwed at the end.

However, if you notice that either coal or oil is having few plants of its type appear, and especially if people quickly stopped running their early coal or oil plants, it can be a good idea to simply by the only two or three of that type that ever come up in the midgame, and be the only one using the resource. If it was cheap enough before you do this, you can run very efficiently. However, if the game puts out too many good plants of that type, you just get screwed trying to do this.


Board position, while important, tends to be a less important factor than plant capacity.
Unless your board play is particularly bad, or someone gets a particularly large area of the board or somethimg, buying the right plants at the right price has a greater impact.

That said, it is of course better to go for the cheap areas of the board, even if there is a bit more competition. One important thing to note is that if you play the cheap connections early and expensive connections late, that is only a tiny bit better than the expensive connections early and cheap ones late. You might expand a little faster and get more money a couple turns, but you pay the same amount for cities in the end. What is more relevant to how good your board position is, is how many cities you get to place the first connection to, and how many the second and third, since each further player pays 5 more to get there. Also important, is to get access to the cheaper areas of the board at SOME point in the game. Making expensive connections early for 10 above the connection costs, and expensive connections later for 20 above the cost as the third player to the city, is bad. Either early or later you need to get at the cheap cities, some way or another. In 2-3 player, this wont be an issue. In 4+ player, it will, as three others can lock you out of an area of the board where the connections are fairly cheap.



Regarding the initial plants, there are advantages and disadvantages to different numbers.

The 1 capacity plants give you less income on turn 1, but you spend less on resources and on the plant as well, and you get to pick first.

The 04 plant is particularly good, in my opinion, as you can buy 4 coal for only 5 on turn 1, AND you will be the first player buying coal on turn 2, so you cna buy two more for cheap then. If you buy a bigger coal plant on turn 2 like the 10, 15, 20, 21 (hybrid) or 25, then you will be able to buy more than 2 coal, relatively inexpensively, and then use the 04 plant as a coal storage facility. You can then leap into the lead in cities, while using your supply of coal purchased inexpensively to avoid buying high cost coal at the bad end of the player order. When you want more coal, you get back into last place in cities for a turn, having picked up extra cash before hand.

The 03 plant is like the 04 but oil is much more expensive, starting at 3. Buying 4 oil on turn 1 is much more painful, and so the use of the 03 as an oil storage facility is not so desirable. I am not fond of the 03.

The 05 is good, you will likely play second, and buy relatively cheap coal, while having more versatility later on.

The 06 is a pile of garbage, as it burns garbage that costs 7. These early plants tend to be used only a couple times anyway, so you dont want to be paying 7 for a garbage to run your 1 capacity plant when you could be buring two, cheaper oil or coal instead. There will always be a better choice than the 6.

The 07 is a good plant, 3 oil for 2 capacity. Its a bit worse is the 03 is in play, but at least that 03 wont be run much, and neither will your 07. You gain 11 from powering another city, but you pay 9-13 in costs for 3 oil instead of 2 for two coal with the 4, so your gain is actually only a few bucks. As a tradeoff for these few extra bucks, you go in a worse position in the turn order later, and so get worse plant chances and worse prices for materials.

The 08 is also good, but probably worse than the 07. Generally the 04 and 05 are bought, and the 05 player will buy 2 coal, so you are paying 3 per coal, like the 07 player is paying for oil.

If the 03 plant is out, then this 08 is better than the 07 however. The disadvantage in return for extra money is you go late in placing cities and buying raw materials, and early in auctions.

If I had to rate these four plants, I would say:

04, 07, 08, 05. But difference between say the 04 and 07 is not so much that I would pay more than a couple extra buck for the 04.

The 09 is good, only 1 oil to power 1 plant, so its only about 4 a turn to run. It can be run in the early midgame efficiently, while things like the 03 and 04 really cant.
The 10 is also good, but if the 04, 05 and 08 are all out, you are going to get screwed on coal prices.


I tend to think that the advantage of playing cities first is more than the advantage of a few extra bucks from a 2 capacity plant. When you play first, you should play in a relatively cheap area of the board, hopefully such that no one can go in behind you and steal the cheap area. Also very good is to play in a more expensive area which BLOCKS a small cheap area behind it (which is too small for anyone else to play in). Thus, no one will go through you because its too expensive (at least not early), and you get some cheap cities when you want them.

The advantage of this is that you guarantee access to those cheap areas of the board at SOME time. If you dont get them early, and then people block you off from them late, that hurts. This is clearly more critical in 4+ player than in 4 player.

BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复
3楼
发表于 2009-10-23 23:16:00|只看该作者
占楼编辑
BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复
4楼
发表于 2009-10-23 23:31:47|只看该作者
非常感激楼主的辛勤翻译
BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复
5楼
发表于 2009-10-23 23:32:33|只看该作者
占楼远观
BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复
6楼
发表于 2009-10-24 02:35:26|只看该作者
很棒的文章,更棒的翻译
BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复
7楼
发表于 2009-10-24 07:33:45|只看该作者
{:3_78:}
BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复
8楼
发表于 2009-10-24 13:44:38|只看该作者
不错。。支持
其实电厂。。个人喜欢5
BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复
9楼
发表于 2009-10-24 21:09:48|只看该作者
支持支持。

但是有一点,在多人(4+)的游戏中,最早造城市的人有时候可能会被围困起来,而不能发挥最早选择的地理优势……当然这个取决于玩的地图。
BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复
10楼
发表于 2009-10-25 10:30:24|只看该作者
开了几次电厂,没赢过,还垫过底
拜读拜读
BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复
11楼
发表于 2009-10-25 11:41:04|只看该作者
谢谢楼主的文。我想转贴到我们智游的电厂专区,呵呵。
BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复
12楼
发表于 2009-10-25 23:10:44|只看该作者
谢谢楼主的文。我想转贴到我们智游的电厂专区,呵呵。
tick 发表于 2009-10-25 11:41


没问题!

顺便BS一下不经他人同意转贴的可憎行径
BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复
13楼
发表于 2009-10-26 22:56:26|只看该作者
Very Good

很好的文章。赞一个
BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复
14楼
发表于 2009-10-29 09:48:21|只看该作者
初学电厂的飘过
BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复
15楼
发表于 2009-11-26 20:00:19|只看该作者
没玩过,支持一下
BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复
16楼
发表于 2009-12-21 17:03:51|只看该作者
很好的文章。赞一个{:4_156:}
BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复
17楼
发表于 2009-12-21 20:41:49|只看该作者
学习电网中,拜读
BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复
18楼
发表于 2009-12-22 16:46:06|只看该作者
好文.拜读{:4_177:}
BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复
19楼
发表于 2009-12-22 16:55:16|只看该作者
支持一下
BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复
20楼
发表于 2009-12-22 17:10:18|只看该作者
当你先造城市,你应该先造在版图上相对便宜的区域,最好是那些没人能跟着你,偷着进入便宜区域的位置。在一个能够卡住一小块便宜区域的稍贵一点的区域发展也是非常不错的(那一小块区域不足以让一个人在里面发展)。另外,没人能够通过你,因为那太贵了(至少不能太近),然后你就可以随心所欲的取得哪些便宜的城市。

就是有人非要进去那一小块区域,明知会被卡死,也不让你独占便宜。

结果就是此2人死磕,其他人哈哈笑

所以,别选那最好的一块区域
BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复

全部版块|BGC桌游网

历史存档数据冻结于 2026-09 · GMT+8, 2026-11-23 06:54