数据已迁移全部帖子与账号都已迁入新论坛,认领后即可继续你的老账号:立即认领账号 ↗前往新站
BGC桌游网 · 历史存档(只读)

BGC桌游网

本站为 BGC桌游网 历史存档,仅供浏览与回忆;登录与发帖已关闭,新讨论请前往新论坛。
BGC桌游网»全部版块 › 桌游主讨论区 › 桌面战棋专区 › 最近研究advanced squad leader sk系类总结
查看: 2,766|回复: 9
上一主题下一主题

最近研究advanced squad leader sk系类总结

[历史存档]
1楼
发表于 2010-2-2 14:10:47|只看该作者
系统设定与实际的关系类:
为什么有的班长是单独的列出?
Leadership is abstracted in ASL. If you actually included a counter for every sergeant and corporal present,
you would have far more leaders than squads. The leaders that are present in every squad are assumed to be
doing their job competently, so they are factored into the squad’s ratings and do not appear as separate leader
counters. The leaders that do appear in counter form are the few that perform above average, and who thus
might be able to influence the course of the battle. In other words, they are the leaders who make a difference.

为什么美军的士气要比德军低?
If you compare the American and German 1st Line squads, the Americans are more likely to break when fired upon (Morale 6 vs 7); but flip these squads over to their broken sides and look at the difference. The broken side of a squad’s counter has only one combat value: that squad’s broken Morale Level. The American broken Morale is 8, while the German broken Morale is 7... the higher number is better, so the Americans will rally much more easily than the Germans.What’s happening here is this: when an American squad fails a Morale Check and breaks, it likely hasn’t really
panicked... the troops are simply keeping their heads down. This makes it relatively easy for a leader to rally them and get them back into the fight. A German squad is less likely to break, but when it does break it really is panicked, and it will be more difficult for a leader to rally them from a panicked state.

为什么美军步兵班火力要比其他国家的强?
An American rifle squad would normally have one soldier using a Browning Automatic Rifle (BAR), which does
not quite qualify as a true light machine gun and so never appears as a separate support weapon counter,
seven soldiers with M1 Garand semi-automatic rifles, and a sergeant and a corporal armed with either M1s or
submachine guns. The American FP advantage over similar German, British, and Russian rifle squads comes
from the semi-automatic rifles, which can fire far faster than any bolt-action rifle.

为什么射击相邻的格子里的敌人,我方火力*2?
(a) it is much easier to hit a nearby target; and
(b) when firing into an adjacent hex the range is close enough that hand grenades can be used

为什么班溃散后会做降格处理或损耗处理?
Casualties in ASL are handled in a somewhat abstract manner, in order to avoid having to track casualties on a
man by man basis:
1.A squad that breaks can be thought of as having suffered light casualties.
2.A squad that breaks and is replaced by a lower quality squad can be thought of as having suffered casualties
among key personnel, causing it to become less effective.
3.A squad that is casualty reduced (K result) to a half squad (HS) has suffered heavy casualties.
4.A squad that is eliminated due to a Killed in Action (KIA) result has suffered catastrophic casualties.

为什么会有残余火力值?
When a unit fires in ASL, it is, with only a few exceptions, actually firing throughout the entire player turn. If a
unit moves into a hex and is fired upon, and then later in the turn another unit moves into the same hex, that
second unit can possibly run into some of the bullets that are being aimed at the first unit. Residual FP is how
ASL handles this possibility: if you move a unit into a hex containing a Residual FP counter, you will be attacked
immediately by that Residual FP, prior to any separate attacks that might be aimed specifically at you.

为什么前进射击阶段火力值除2?
Advancing Fire is less effective than Prep Fire, because units that are moving cannot fire with the volume or
accuracy of units that do not move. Units that have the Assault Fire bonus are equipped with semi-automatic
rifles and/or submachine guns—weapons that are easy to fire while moving—and have trained in using them in that manner.

为什么投掷两个骰子点数一样会导致cowering?
Cowering in ASL originally confuses a lot of players, because you normally think of cowering as something that
occurs when you are fired upon, rather than when you are firing. In other words, how can being ordered to
fire on the enemy cause you to cower? But most actions in a turn of ASL are actually occurring simultaneously,
even though the turn itself is broken into sequential steps for ease of play. So while the Germans are firing at
the Americans, the Americans are also firing as they approach the German position (even though such firing
will not be resolved until the AFPh). In most situations, you can’t fire at the enemy without exposing yourself to
their fire, so when you roll doubles some of your soldiers have decided that they would just as soon stay under
cover this turn and not be shot at, which reduces your firing effectiveness by requiring you to resolve the shot
using the next lowest IFT column.





技巧类:
ASL原则:
1.Stack only when you have a valid reason to do so。(善用”kill stack“)
2.Think about moving before you think about Prep Firing

7原则
因为7是掷色子的期望值,所以当你决定是否射击的时候,首先看看如果投掷结果是7后?(再加上修正值),效果怎样的,然后在决定打不打,怎样打

8-0之类的班长的如何用?
Leaders with a Leadership Modifier of zero give little benefit in actual fighting, so they are often used behind
the front lines to rally broken troops.其实也可以留在前线,防止其他部队射击时发生“cower事件”,哈哈。

火力组齐射还是几次单独射击?
You will find a lot of different opinions as to whether it is better to make two weak attacks or one strong attack,but a general rule is that the better the defensive terrain the more need there is to make a single strong attack.If the Germans were in Open Ground (+0 TEM) or maybe even woods (+1 TEM), it is possible that two weak attacks might actually have a better overall chance of breaking them... but since they are in a stone building (+3 TEM) a combined attack is going to give the Americans their best chance.

空地上移动怎么办?
Assault Movement 防止敌人的FFNAM);多放烟雾弹
BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复
2楼
发表于 2010-2-2 14:18:55|只看该作者
这篇文事richfam的那本手册里我觉得前几章最有用的东西(系统为什么这样设定 与实际的关系,以及部分技巧),涉及SK1吧,我从来没见过这么好的手册,把东西讲的这么清晰(好过原版的rule book),建议各位去看看
BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复
3楼
发表于 2010-2-2 16:47:53|只看该作者
应该也属于designer’s note 之类的吧,不错的东西,请问这手册哪里下载?
BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复
4楼
发表于 2010-2-2 17:06:17|只看该作者
http://www.boardgamegeek.com/filepage/40482/jay-richardsons-asl-starter-kit-tutorials-properly
手册在这 其实也不是什么designer note,就是一个tutorial,只不过里边穿插了这个人(并非作者,只是一个BoardGameGeek的资深网友)的理解(为什么要这样设定,与实际的联系)和实践总结出的几个技巧。
BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复
5楼
发表于 2010-2-2 21:46:28|只看该作者
这篇文事richfam的那本手册里我觉得前几章最有用的东西(系统为什么这样设定 与实际的关系,以及部分技巧) ...
berto 发表于 2010-2-2 14:18


其实这些东西原版说明书里也是有的。
绝大部分内容在ASLRB Chapter A的脚注里都出现了,有得还更详细。
比如PBF,脚注里明确说明了攻击x2主要是手雷因素的影响,这也解释在ASL里,如果被攻击方比攻击方高2个level的时候,PBF攻击是没有x2奖励的 (手雷扔不了那么高,不小心还会掉回来炸了自己 :D)

其实最早的SL,不论是手册还是12个场景,整体编排对初学者非常友好;场景从易到难,逐步引入新的规则。基本上和CoH的规则书一个水平(yahoo的SL群里能下到SL全系列的手册)。
可惜后来随着扩展的增加,修订成ASL,目标用户慢慢就成了对SL系统非常熟悉的玩家了,把对新玩家友好的传统淡化了 .....

从这种意义上说,MMP真应该万分感谢richfam写的那一个系列的tutorial :D

顺便提一下,General上当年的关于Squad Leader的文章都很不错。电驴上能搜到,推荐找来看看,顺便瞻仰一下先贤 ;)
BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复
6楼
发表于 2010-2-2 23:52:08|只看该作者
其实这些东西原版说明书里也是有的。
绝大部分内容在ASLRB Chapter A的脚注里都出现了,有得还更详细。 ...
小p胡 发表于 2010-2-2 21:46


我是初学(推了5 6次吧,看了几篇战报),ASLRB我是想先放放再看,看了兄台的话,忍不住看了几眼 说实话 光看chapter A这60多页,我觉得我就坚持不下去了,感觉知识点是散的,学习曲线太陡了!比看richfam的那130多页的手册,难的多啊!刚开始就钻到ASL的怀抱里 估计是必死无疑的!还有richfam总结的技巧还是挺好的,手册里我暂时没看到(也许在k章的班长训练里?),SL暂时没时间看了,呵呵
BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复
7楼
发表于 2010-2-3 00:21:51|只看该作者

我是初学(推了5 6次吧,看了几篇战报),ASLRB我是想先放放再看,看了兄台的话,忍不住看了几眼 说实话 光看chapter A这60多页,我觉得我就坚持不下去了,感觉知识点是散的,学习曲线太陡了!比看richfam的那130多页的手册,难的多啊!刚开始就钻到ASL的怀抱里 估计是必死无疑的!还有richfam总结的技巧还是挺好的,手册里我暂时没看到(也许在k章的班长训练里?),SL暂时没时间看了,呵呵


rulebook真的完全就是for your reference;不适合学习入门,但是有非常详细的cross reference和annotate。
每一个chapter的最后一个部分,是对整个chapter的footnote :D
顺便说,你有看Eddy M. ...Rio的Example of Play吗?我觉得这个和tutorial一起,就可忽略Chapter K了。Chapter K写的絮絮叨叨,可看性很低。

至于技巧,试着自己总结难道不是更有意思 :P
BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复
8楼
发表于 2010-2-3 08:15:21|只看该作者
你好!我是Lorricount,香港的兵棋爱好者。我已翻译了ASLSK1的规则成中文,现正翻译ASLSK2的规则中,望于年底前完成。我已玩了ASL十多年,但较喜欢ASLSK。ASL的学习方法,着重从游戏中学习。我当年也是跟一些懂ASL的玩家,一起玩游戏,从中慢慢学习的。现已有超过2000多个Scenario,大部份ASL Scenario,可用ASLSK规则来玩,每周玩1个Scenario,也可玩40年,这就是ASLSK强项。如各位到香港,可通知我,安排到Hong Kong Society of Wargamers www.hksw.org 玩ASL。另外,我会将在4 5 6 月 左右举办香港第2年ASL比赛。
BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复
9楼
发表于 2010-2-3 11:36:54|只看该作者
回复 8# lorricount


专程仰慕lorricount来了
BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复
10楼
发表于 2010-2-3 14:31:56|只看该作者
你好!我是Lorricount,香港的兵棋爱好者。我已翻译了ASLSK1的规则成中文,现正翻译ASLSK2的规则中,望于年 ...
lorricount 发表于 2010-2-3 08:15



欢迎Lorricount,希望多来这里发战报和经验介绍。

我这个月应该会到手ASLSK#1/2,向各位学习。
BGC桌游网 历史存档 · 不可回复

全部版块|BGC桌游网

历史存档数据冻结于 2026-09 · GMT+8, 2026-11-22 01:21