http://boardgamegeek.com/thread/772393/best-platoon-level-ww2-game/page/2
finally some ppl say something worth noting
I'm late to this thread, but for posterity's sake I'd like to post anyways...
I'm only qualified to talk about Panzer Grenadier, so that's all I will talk about cool
Why People Don't Like PG
You can roughly divide these folks into three groups: (edit to add that there are certainly other reasons, but these are the ones I hear the most)
1) Early Adopters who bought an ugly duckling and gave up before it became a swan The series didn't really become something thoroughly enjoyable until the 3rd edition rules hit in 2006. Most of the negative comments about the game that you can find in the BGG Comments sections are referring to these older rules. They drove a lot of potential players away, and many of those folks never came back for a second look. You can't blame them. We all want games to be good on Day One, not Year 6!
2) People who don't "get" the scale of the game PG is like the A-Team, lots of bullets are fired but no one ever really dies. Even units removed from the board due to compound step losses aren't really dead, they've just become wholly combat ineffective for the duration of the battle. PG is platoon level, and strictly so. This means that battles require time to develop, that assaults to contest a hex can take an hour or more of in-game time to resolve (4+ turns), that patiently prepping a target with artillery fire over several turns is often absolutely necessary for any hope of successful attack, etc. PG really shines when you set up one of the big scenarios: 8 maps, hundreds of counters, 80+ turns. That's where you really witness the ebb and flow of battle, where flanks really are flanks, where timely arrival of reinforcements can change everything...
3) People who don't "get" the leadership system The heart of PG is the leadership. Competently managing your chain of command will allow you to strike swiftly and flexibly, incompetently managing your CoC will result in leaderless units strung out across the battlefield unable to do much more than shit their pants. If you don't coordinate your forces, or if you are careless and let a few too many leaders catch bullets during the course of battle, you will absolutely end up in a very unfun situation where you cannot do anything productive. This can be disheartening to a beginner, and maddening to a veteran, but it is perfectly "fair" considering the design goals of the system.
having said that...
Why People Like PG
There are lots of reasons but I'll highlight a few here...
1) The complexity PG is not a complex wargame. Even the dimwit can expect to have 90% of the rules in his head after only 3 or 4 scenarios. However, the nature of this simplicity still allows for compelling gameplay, and meaningful differences between nationalities and between time periods. The rules provide enough structure for satisfying historical gaming without getting in the way.
2) The variety The only major WW2 participant still wholly absent from PG is China. There are 28 playable nations - 28! There are currently 1,135 different units. Some of those repeat - many nations have INF for example - but there are still many, many hundreds of unique units to play with. I believe only ASL surpasses PG in this regard, but PG is much cheaper to buy into!
3) Solitaire suitability Everything is better with others, but PG does play very well solitaire due to its alternating activations system. Hidden unit scenarios aren't so nice, but with 1,600 scenarios to choose from and counting, you have a lot of options.
4) Panzer Grenadier Headquarters This is my site, so of course I'm biased, but I am confident there is no better wargame series support site on the internet for any other series. Not only do we catalog the entire, vast PG universe, we have a comprehensive play tracker, over a thousand after action reports, and are continuously developing and adding new features to support the PG player...
And just for funsies I'll announce it here for the first time to see if anyone is still reading: this summer we will launch an automated double-blind referee. Two (or more) players will be able to log in to PG-HQ and it will host DB games for them, handling all of the line of sight and spotting checks and revealing only those units which you can see. You and your opponent will both set up the game on your own tables, and play over voice chat. As far as I know, there is nothing else like it for other tabletop wargames. It will be pretty awesome.
So yeah, PG had a rough start but it's a nice series to be into these days, and getting better all the time. |