本帖最后由 anf 于 2013-7-28 22:33 编辑
37. Board Game: Police Precinct [Average Rating:7.31 Overall Rank:1191]
 Our rating:           Addictive?  Long Term Replayability:  Skill Factor: Low-Moderate Modes: Co-op, Solo, Hidden Traitor Players: 1-6 With a couple: Slight variant; you have extra "NPC" cop cars to move around. Works fine. Play Time: 1-2 hours Difficulty: Low. Some scaling options. Individual/Group Play: Rewards group play.
Mini-Review Police Precinct is a Pandemic style game; you try to manage various short term threats while also working to solve a relatively unconnected long term goal. Most of the game is moving around a board trying to stop the most threatening crisis. I suppose a lot of co-ops can be boiled down to that, but this one, while not looking much like Pandemic, just had a lot of the same feel to me. Each player controls a police officer, and you drive around the city trying to stop crimes in progress and street gangs while also investigating a murder. Many actions are luck driven; dice to stop crimes, card draws to find evidence. Players have hands of bonus cards that they can play on anyone else's action, so you can all pitch in a bit. You can also get a bonus by having another player along when you take an action. Its solid and playable. There's technically a bit more variety than Pandemic - you can even "level up" your cop to improve your stats (though we rarely have found it worth the time to do so). However, the decisions generally haven't felt as interesting, and overall the game is a bit bland. We have liked playing it, but after a few plays when we've got have rarely bothered to go back to it. The game also is designed for a "dirty cop" traitor variant where one player works against the team. We have not and probably will not played that way, but my impression is that it shares the flaws that I dislike about most traitor games, where the traitor and players don't so much play against each other as the traitor simply tries to play badly. A few of the traitor mechanics look particularly poorly thought out, such as a card that involves a bid between the players; it would be exceedingly silly for anyone to actually bid against each other - just pick a random player to get the card! As a minor pet peeve, since they bothered to make the police officer cards double sided anyway, and the markers are just cars, why not include a female character on one side and a male on the other to be more gender inclusive?
Get if for: * A police theme for a basic co-op game. * A solid game with a decent amount of mechanical variety. * Optional traitor game play.
Avoid it if: * You've already got a Pandemic-style game and want to keep your collection small. * You don't like a heavy dice influence.
38. Board Game: Princess Ryan's Star Marines [Average Rating:5.31 Overall Rank:8128
NOT A CO-OP Rating:           This older game is cited as a co-op every now and then. While it "looks" like a team (the Star Marines) vs. one player (the Dark Legion), and there are rules for automating the Dark Legion, that doesn't make it cooperative. The main part of the marine game is focused on trying to score individual points in each encounter, which you do by playing a higher card than your allies. Try to play full co-op and this all collapses. It might be possible to come up with a co-op variant, however. 39. Board Game: Prophecy [Average Rating:6.75 Overall Rank:742
 Our rating:           Addictive?  Long Term Replayability:  Skill Factor: Moderate. Mix of skill and luck. Modes: Competitive, Co-op/Solo with Dragon Realm expansion or variant. Players: 1-6 With a couple: Plays very well. Play Time: 2-3 hours. Difficulty: Not enough plays to be sure. Individual/Group Play: Doesn't discourage group play, but has more of an individual feel to it.
Mini-Review One of Chvatil's less successful games. Prophecy is a fantasy adventure with very clear inspiration from Talisman. Travel around the board, fight monsters, gain treasures and power, and seek to claim the artifacts to win the game. While the original game is competitive, the Dragon Realm expansion included a cooperative variant. However, the BGGer Deebs has posted an even better co-op variant using just the base game! However, even if you just want to play the variant, the Dragon Realm expansion does give you alternative cards to use in a co-op game to replace the PvP skill cards. The main difference from Talisman is in less randomness and more interesting character development. Instead of rolling a die to move around a board, you travel a consistent one space per turn, but can spend gold to use horses and ships to travel faster. Characters start out all pretty much the same, but you can diversify a lot by learning "skills" which are available in various guilds throughout the game. It's a solid fantasy adventure game, but a bit long for what it is. The Dragon Realm is also marred by a misprinting; key board elements are completely wrong!
Get if for: * Fantasy adventure. * Lots of ways to build up a character. * Lots of cards worth of different monsters, gear and encounters. * You like Talisman, but feel it's too random.
Avoid it if: * You like Talisman, but wish it was a bit more random. * You like Talisman, but think it's too long. * You aren't going to enjoy wandering around a board rolling dice to "fight" random monsters. 40. Board Game: Quest Cards [Average Rating:4.70 Overall Rank:8014]
Our rating:           Addictive?   Long Term Replayability:   Skill Factor: This should perhaps be a 0, but there's no '0' side on a d6. This is pure luck. Modes: Claimed Co-op, Competitive Players: 2- With a couple: No worse than with any other number. Play Time: 30 minutes or less. Difficulty: No idea. Individual/Group Play: Not enough skill to matter.
Mini-Review A dungeon adventure card game. Some cards form a map of an area (a castle or a mountain in the two provided scenarios). You travel around the map, flipping cards over to explore them and fighting the monsters you find. When you find a monster or trap, you roll dice to see if you beat it. Items modify your rolls and chances. If there is any skill (and I'm not sure there is), it's only there in small amounts. In the normal game, you race against the other players to complete an objective. While the game claims to be playable co-op, and includes rules for players forming a party, there's no mention made of what to use as the goal for a co-op game. One thing I do like about the game is how they handled improving skills; a skill normally has four levels; two each on each side of a card. Flip a card upside down when you advance it to level 2 to see the level 2 skill. Turn it over when you get to level 3. Flip it back rightside up for level 4. A nice and convenient way of tracking variable skills. If you actually want to play an essentially mindless game, and come up with a good objective for solo/co-op, it's not all that bad. I realize that's strange to say, but...just wandering around and seeing if you beat the monsters and gain new skills can be kind of fun.
Get if for: * Mindless adventure. * A nice skill mechanic. * A game for kids who aren't ready to make decisions anyway.
Avoid it if: * You want stratey. Or tactics. Or choices. Or the illusion of choices. * You actually want co-op rules. * I could go on, but if you haven't been put off already, I don't think any of the other flaws are really that important. 41. Board Game: Rabbit [Average Rating:5.80 Unranked]
 Our rating:           Addictive?  Long Term Replayability:  Skill Factor: Hard to say. Moderate? Some skill in resource managment, a chunk of luck in exploration and event cards. Modes: Solo Players: 1-2. Well, sort of 2. With a couple: This is really a solo game. With 2 player, you just share the pieces. Play Time: 20-30 minutes Difficulty: Hard to say. Individual/Group Play: This is a one player game. Even sharing pieces, resources are critically limited and each move must be considered very carefully for the whole group.
Mini-Review I really want to like this. The theme - growing a group of rabbits - is different and cool, and the mechanics look interesting. I really, really, want to like it. But...I feel like it's a rough prototype of a game, with rules that don't really quite work. First, "co-op" play consists of "share the pieces". But resources are so incredibly tight that you really need to consider each move very carefully, so in practice you are really just discussing what moves to make. Resource scarcity should be an interesting element. But in Rabbit, it's just such a limitation that moves wind up being very obvious. There are several options that you are just never going to use because they aren't resource efficient enough, and the game requires brutal efficiency. Not a lot to say here. We played once or twice and were dissappointed. We've pondered house rules but never came up with anything.
Get if for: * A unique and different theme.
Avoid it if: * You have ever, ever complained that co-ops are really solo games or uttered the phrase "alpha player". * Your tastes remotely align with ours and you don't want to be fairly bored while playing a game. 42. Board Game: Red November [Average Rating:6.43 Overall Rank:895]
 Our rating:           Addictive?  Long Term Replayability:  Skill Factor: Mostly luck of the dice Modes: Co-op, sorta traitor Players: 1-8 With a couple: We usually play 2 gnomes each, which is easy to do. Play Time: 45 min - 1 hour, longer with more players. Difficulty: Moderate. Very luck dependnt. Individual/Group Play: Not really enough skill to matter much. Some coordination and commitee planning is helpful.
Mini-Review Ah, the fun of trying to stay alive on a leaking, burning, malfunctioning submarine. While drunk! The players control gnomes on an ill-fated submarine which is having everything go wrong. Your gnomes run around rolling dice to try fix these disasters and keep the sub alive long enough to be rescued. The game uses a "time" based turn mechanic; the player fartherest back on the time track takes a turn, moving their marker forward based on how many actions they take. Move 1 space? 1 minute. Try to fix a problem? 1 minute per 1/10 chance of success you want. There's not a lot of depth to this. Ideally, you want to choose to fix something by taking the exact amount of time as the number you are going to roll. Because, if you take 5 minutes and roll a 6, you failed to fix it and wasted five minutes. If you take 10 minutes and roll a 6, you did at least fix it, but wasted 4 minutes. Since you have no idea what you are going to roll, this is just random guessing. (An old adage applies here: If you don't have time to do it right, you don't have time to do it twice!) As each gnome's time track advances, you pass spaces that force you to draw new disastrous event cards. But, since you need to get to the nd of th time track to be rescued, you have to get past them. This is actually a pretty amusing game. It's fun to around the ship and watch it sink and flood and scramble like crazy trying to fix it all. But if ocean were as shallow as the gameplay, the gnomes could just walk to land. There's a traitor rule included, where at a certain point a gnome could potentially abandon ship, and then wins if everyone else loses. We've never used it; aside from not being interested in a traitor game, it doesn't look like a very good rule to us, with poor interaction between a traitor and non-traitors.
Get if for: * An very portable game IF you can find the 1st edition. They went with a full size box in the later version, thus defeating one of the game's best points. * Chaotic silly dice rolling. * Laughing at misfortune. * A co-op that plays up to 8. I have no ideas how it is with more than 4 though; it seems like it could drag a lot.
Avoid it if: * You want a game that's not almost all luck. * You are averse to random misfortune. * You don't want player elimination in a game.
43. Board Game: Robinson Crusoe: Adventure on the Cursed Island [Average Rating:8.05 Overall Rank:182]
评分:           上瘾度 一般 长期可重玩性:  策略因素:  模式: 合作、单人 2人:有变体规则 个人/小组游戏: 强烈偏向小组 基本信息:1-4人,60~120分钟,难度根据场景而不同但普遍较难 简评:工人放置。探索岛屿,收集食物和补给品,打猎…….。有多个场景,不同的挑战。 你可以得到:巧妙的挑战;不同的场景;结合了工人放置、探索、建设 无视,如果你:游戏玩家中有人总想当老大;觉得优化资源收集计划很无聊
44. Board Game: Sentinels of the Multiverse [Average Rating:7.74 Overall Rank:103]
 评分:           上瘾度  长期可重玩性:  策略因素:  模式: 合作 2人:1人玩2个英雄 个人/小组游戏: 混合 基本信息:2-5人,60分钟,难度根据游戏初始和坏人选择有很大变化 简评:卡牌游戏,超能力战斗。 你可以得到:和主题结合紧密的行动;大量变化;很酷的角色 无视,如果你:不喜欢大量加减法
45. Board Game: Shadowrift [Average Rating:7.47 Overall Rank:1446]
 评分:            上瘾度  长期可重玩性:  策略因素: -  模式: 合作 2人:不错 个人/小组游戏: 混合 基本信息:2-6人,90~120分钟,难度通常低 简评:合作牌组构建。和怪物对抗,保卫城镇 你可以得到:主题牌组构建;面对不同挑战;根据英雄卡的不同游戏差异很大 无视,如果你:介意每回合计算太多
46. Board Game: Shadows over Camelot [Average Rating:7.13 Overall Rank:238]
 Our rating:           Addictive?  Long Term Replayability:  Skill Factor: Moderate Modes: Traitor, Co-op suggested only for learning the game Players: 3-7 With a couple: Unplayable as written, but you can play it as a co-op by using 2 knights each and ignoring the traitor rules. Play Time: 1-2 hours, depending on player count Difficulty: Low as a co-op. Not enough experience with a traitor to judge. Individual/Group Play: Leans towards group play, though it's not clear how much you are allowed to discuss. With the traitor, the game can force group play even more, as you don't want to just let a player make mistakes; 'making mistakes' could be an indicator that the player is the traitor.
Mini-Review. I'm not sure Shadows should even be on this list, but there were several requests for it. Shadows sets the players as knights of the round table, attempting to complete a variety of quests to stop the forces that would destroy Camelot. On each turn, you take an Evil action (either drawing a card from the evil deck, adding a siege engine to the attack on Camelot, or losing a life) and then take a Good action (moving, drawing cards, or playing a card to complete a quest). The knights try to gather enough white swords from completing quests to win the game, while too many black swords (from failing quests) will make them lose. Most of the gameplay is driven by a deck of cards, that contains a lot of standard quest cards (mostly 'Fight' cards of values 1-5, which are used on several quests) and a few special cards. While most of the game is co-op, normal play includes a traitor. At the start of the game, you deal a face down 'loyalty' card to each player. The deck of 8 cards contains 7 'Loyal' cards and one 'Traitor' card. You use the full deck each time, so there's not necessarily a traitor (in fact, a lot of the games we've played had no traitor by random deal!). The traitor wins if the knights lose. To this end, they can try to fare badly on quests, or add siege engines to the castle at bad times, or even capture Lancelot's armor which lets you secretly pick which of two evil cards to play each turn (very good for a Loyal knight to have...very nasty for the Traitor to have!) I'm not overly fond of the traitor dynamic. While I think the concept is interesting, in practice the traitor mostly just tries to play poorly, but not so poorly that they are noticed. Or, they just play obviously and reveal themselves but still cause trouble (possibly by just adding a siege engine to Camelot every turn). Or, if the game starts going badly for the knights as is, they just act like a normal knight and let the white -> black swords flips that happen for failing to find a traitor defeat the knights. None of these options seem like much fun to me. Granted, I've only played two games that actually included a traitor, so I can't judge very accurately. In one of these games, by the way, the traitor was a new player and felt very frustrated; he felt like he could never do anything traitorous because his moves were being too heavily dictated. The rest of the game play is decent, if abstract. You try to manage your hand of cards, figure out which quests you can complete and which ones you want to stall or abandon. Because moving from quest to quest is costly, you'll often make a decision about which quest to undertake which will determine your actions for a few turns in a row. There are a few oddly unthematic elements to the game. For example, you don't want to complete the Excalibur or Grail quests too early in the game. Once these quests are completed, the evil cards that normally play on those quests instead add siege engines, which are overall worse. The game is wonderfully produced, with miniatures for the knights, invaders, siege engines. The boards and cards have lovely and colorful illustrations. If you want a game for groups of 4+, like the traitor mechanic, and don't mind the somewhat abstract nature of the game, I think this is a great game to add to your collection with a lot of visual appeal. I wouldn't recommend playing too much in a row though, as it can become repetitive pretty quickly. If you're considering it for a true co-op or won't usually have a group of 4+, don't bother. We have played it as a co-op with the two of us controlling two knights each. This was fun for a play or two, but didn't hold up for long.
Get if for: * A visually gorgeous game with wonderful components. * Simple but tense gameplay. * The paranoia of having a traitor in your midst.
Avoid it if: * You are looking for a true co-op. * You are bored by abstracted mechanics. * You'll be bothered by unclear communication rules.
47. Board Game: Space Alert [Average Rating:7.64 Overall Rank:59]
 评分:           上瘾度  长期可重玩性:  策略因素: Almost all skill. 模式: 合作、单人 2人:可以,但乐趣不如人多 个人/小组游戏: 鼓励个人 基本信息:1-5人(最好4~5人),30分钟,难度变化很大 简评:我们最爱的合作类游戏。实时历险,大量行动,让一个太空船保持航行 你可以得到:紧张的行动;大量玩家互动、笑声、惊叫;精巧的计划,谜题挑战 无视,如果你:不喜欢实时
48为47的扩展
49. Board Game: Space Cadets [Average Rating:7.21 Overall Rank:550]
 Our rating:           Modes: Co-op Players: 3-6 With a couple: Not 2 player playable as written. You could probably spread out the stations between 2 players if you wanted to. Play Time: Listed at 1.5 hours. Our first play added about an hour just to set up and teach. Difficulty: Not sure. Scenario based, so it will vary. Individual/Group Play: Generally individual, as there is very little interaction at all.
Quick Overview Command a ship by playing 30 second mini-games! That about says it all. You are the crew of a spaceship, and you navigate it around and fire weapons and power shields by means of playing little minigames of Ubongo and Memory Match (I wish I were kidding about that one) and Take it Easy and such. Each round, you have about 30 seconds during which each player plays their minigame. While the gameplay is light and the individual games are simple, there are a lot of them and a lot of rules to explain. Teaching this game for our first play was pretty nightmarish, and it ran long in total. Some of the mini games are fun (like the robo-rally-esque) ship handling. Some are much less fun (Memory match?! Seriously?) If all of your group dislikes the same game (Memor...ok, you get the idea) the play experience will suffer. There's very little interaction overall; you each just rush to do your own little puzzle.
50. Board Game: Space Hulk: Death Angel - The Card Game [Average Rating:7.00 Overall Rank:344]
 Our rating:           Addictive? - Avg - Long Term Replayability:   Skill Factor: There is skill and planning in setting up actions, but a lot of planning can be crushed by a few bad die rolls. Modes: Co-op, Solo Players: 1-6* * The more players you have, the more likely you are to have player elimination. With a couple: Plays well, but you have to control two squads each. Since each squad is two characters to begin with, I don't know how the "only want to play one character" crowd will feel about it. Play Time: 1.5 - 2 hours Difficulty: Overall low Individual/Group Play: Strongly discourages individuality. The entire group must plan together for actions to be useful.
Mini-Review A team of elite Space Marines journeys into the pathways of an ancient derelict starship to control swarms of deadly alien foes. Death Angel is a co-op card game version of the classic skirmish boardgame. Rather than having a board or map to move around on, the marines are formed into a line and can face either left or right. Various locations along the line offer places to interact with and sources for the genestealers to spawn. The marines must progress though an area by cleaering at least one of the two spawn decks for each location, eventually reaching the final mission target. There are a few mission objectives with slightly different conditions. You might need to wipe out all the genestealers in the last room, or escape from the space hulk. Each player controls one or more squads of two marines. On a turn, everyone picks an action card for each marine squad. You can move or support or attack. You can't play the same card twice in a row, so you need to plan ahead; if you shoot one turn, you can't shoot the next! You also need to plan carefully with the other players. Because you can only take one action each turn, if you need to shoot a genestealer that's out of range, you'll need someone else to make the move that will put you in range. The different marine teams have a nice mix of special abilities, and there's a decent variety of locations to encounter to keep the game fresh. The game does a good job of capturing the feel of the boardgame. There's a lot of tension as you fight through the Space Hulk, and a decent challenge in figuring out the right moves. However, the luck factor can be crushingling frustrating; you've often got no chance but to rely on 50/50 rolls to come out well. Our first game was lost entirely on rolling five 0's in a row. While this has some good things going for it, it hasn't held up well with us; we haven't felt like there's enough gameplay there to keep us coming back after our first few plays. Due to the extremely high amount of coordination, it lends itself to having a few players play for the group. Between this, a long playtime, and player elimination, we usually haven't been interested in taking it to gaming groups.
Get if for: * Tense and thematic action. * A lot of game in a small package. * Tricky puzzle card planning situations.
Avoid it if: * Your group minds player elimination. * You have worries about a bossy player running the show. * You mind having lots of tough planning crushed by a bad die roll.
51. Board Game: Spellbound [Average Rating:6.86 Overall Rank:2145]
 评分:           上瘾度  长期可重玩性: 平均 策略因素: Moderate. 模式: 合作、单人 2人:不错 个人/小组游戏: 非常偏向于小组 基本信息:1-4人,30~45分钟,难度低但可增加 简评:配件很大、很酷、很雷。牌组构建,所有人共享一个牌组。 你可以得到:很大的配件;巧妙的牌组构建和手牌管理 无视,如果你:介意玩小组游戏;不喜欢占地太大的游戏;真的想买(绝版了)
52. Board Game: Star Trek: Expeditions [Average Rating:6.64 Overall Rank:1088
 Our rating:           Addictive?  Long Term Replayability:  Skill Factor: Low. Some planning, but luck of the dice rules. Modes: Co-op, Solo Players: 1-4 With a couple: Supposed to play normally 2 player, but we've always played two characters each. Play Time: 1 hour Difficulty: 3 difficulty settings; overall low difficulty. Individual/Group Play: Generally encourages group decisions.
Mini-Review To boldy go where no Clix models have gone before! Star Trek Expeditions puts you in command of the bridge crew of the Enterprise (the new movie version), journeying to a plant in peril and attempting to resolve diplomatic and scientific crises while battling a Klingon takeover. Most of the game consists of moving to a spot and making a skill check, modified by cards you can play. Succeed at checks to make progess in events. You need to balance which tasks you have the skills to complete successfully and which tasks are more urgent. The game uses WizKids (in?)famous clix dial system, which means you constantly have to check little numbers on the dial. It also means that your abilities degrade as you get hurt, so there can be snowball effects from failing. There's flavor text on the various task cards, but they are really all pretty samey. Move to the spot, roll some dice, see if you make progress or take some damage. A major/minor* part of the game is the fight between the Klingon cruiser and the Enterprise. Which consists of occasionally rolling some dice to see which ship damages the other. Hey, at least you can play some cards (which you needed to draw randomly) to influence the outcome. * The ship battle is very important to how well you do in the game. In fact, it's one of the most important factors to your overall score. In that way, it's major. However, you have very little control of it, and almost no decisions to make regarding it. In that way it's minor. In my book, that's not a good combo. My one sentence summary of Star Trek Expeditions? "It's a rental". There's some fun stuff, and seeing the different cards for the first time and figuring out how to manage the system can be interesting. We had fun on our first play, but by play 3 we'd seen everything the game has to offer. Been there, done that. Maybe we'll play again when it's been long enough to forget about it.
Get if for: * Satisfying your co-op Star Trek addiction. * An amsuing game or two of fairly low-theme die rolling. * Having in your collection so you can be nice the one to loan it to other games so they can get in their one or two plays.
Avoid it if: * You want a lot of replay value. * You want an immersive theme in your Star Trek game.
53. Board Game: A Touch of Evil: The Supernatural Game [Average Rating:7.04 Overall Rank:414
 Our rating:           Addictive?  Long Term Replayability:  Skill Factor: Low. Luck of the draw and dice. Modes: Competitive, Co-op, Team Players: 1-8 With a couple: Plays normally. Play Time: 1-2 hours Difficulty: Varies based on the villain, but generally low. Individual/Group Play: Not really enough skill to matter.
Mini-Review A Touch of Evil puts the players into the roles of colonial era investigators squaring off supernatural forces in a small town. The movie Sleepy Hollow was obviously a major inspiration. The mechanics are straighforward; draw an evil card to see what bad stuff happens, then move your characters around a map-like board to find gear and "clues" (basically currency) to power up and fight the villain before time runs out. There's enormous potential here. The characters are cool, and there's a nice variety of stuff that can happen. The game comes with four different villains, each of which plays a bit differently. There's also some major stumbling points. The game really seems designed for competitive play; some cards just don't work well in a co-op game, and the secrets mechanic for the townsfolk barely works in a co-op game at all. There's also a lack of driving force in the game. You just sort of wander around and meet random stuff. There's very little reason to travel to any particular place. The villain occasionally kills town elders, but you can't try to protect them; it doesn't feel like you are interacting with the villain at all until the showdown. If you don't mind that, or can houserule around it, it's a decent game.
Get if for: * Engaging theme. * Nice models and presentation. * A choice of co-op, team and competitive play.
Avoid it if: * You like having real decisions on a normal basis. * You'll mind that some mechanics aren't really meant for a co-op.
54. Board Game: Urbion [Average Rating:7.19 Overall Rank:1555]
 Our rating:           Addictive?  Long Term Replayability:  Skill Factor: Moderate. Modes: Co-op, Solo. Players: 1-2 With a couple: Plays normally. Play Time: 15-30 minutes Difficulty: Moderate. Individual/Group Play: Very group play oriented; lots of planning required.
Mini-Review The 'sequel' to Onirim (with very little in common) has you trying to balance good and bad dreams in dream cities. Each dream has a positive or negative number; if you balance the positives and negatives in a city, you can 'score' it and replace it with a new city. You must balance all 12 cities (of which you have 4 out at a time) to win. Gameplay is pretty straight forward; you either play a card to a city, discard a card in order to swap two cards already on the board, or discard a card to claim all the currently balanced cities. If you run out of cards you lose, so you have to manage your actions carefully. Overall, the game feels like a number puzzle, as you add and swap values to try to get matches. It's a playable game, but we found little excitement or investment in it. The game comes with a few 'modules' to add in, but we haven't gotten to any of those yet, and it's doubtful we ever will.
Get it for: * A number shuffling puzzle. * Planning ahead.
Avoid it if: * You want excitement in your game. * You want strong theme in your game. 55. Board Game: Vanished Planet [Average Rating:5.96 Overall Rank:3157]
 Our rating:           Addictive?  Long Term Replayability:  Skill Factor:  Modes: Co-op Players: 1-6 With a couple: Works great just playing one race each. Play Time: Listed at 1 hour. Difficulty: Easy with the base setup, but very easy to add more 'Creature Growth' cards which will ramp up the difficulty and can make the game very nasty. Individual/Group Play: Slightly encourages playing by committee.
Mini-Review A huge interstellar creature has engulfed the Earth, and spreads outwards towards the other major inhabited worlds. You must find a way to stop it before all life is devoured. I really want to love this game. It's so different from many co-ops. It's got resource productions, building up different technologies, trading resources, traveling around the galaxy. There's a ton of awesome here. However, there awesome is badly impaired by having to manage a lot of building costs, which come in various steps. You'll need a, for example, a Meta-translator to help build a communication array. To build a meta-translator you need a scientist and a two diplomats. To train a scientist you need ore and tech and colonist resources. To train a diplomat you need money and colonist resources. On top of that, the resources are poorly distinguished. All the symbols for different resources are in the same colored sphere, making them hard to tell apart. Cards are sometimes referenced by symbol and sometimes by name, with no clear ready way to tell which which. This is fiddly as hell. Other than that, you rush around trying to accomplish various goals to score enough points to win. You can also build more ships and upgrade your ships with faster drives or teleports. Some goals do seem a lot easier relative to their points than others. The basic game is almost always right down to the last few moments when you win. It does a great job of producing a feel of imminent doom. I really like the gameplay, but the fiddliness of all the build trees and the resource cards is a big downer for us.
Get if for: * Resource gathering and building. * A lot of tension and dread. * Highy scalable difficulty. * Good scaling for multiple player counts.
Avoid it if: * You have ever uttered the word 'fiddly' as a complaint against a game. * You can't keep layers of resource building straight. * You don't see the point of starships that don't have weapons on them. 56. Board Game: Vulkan! [Average Rating:6.29 Overall Rank:5716]
 评论和Feurio一样
57. Board Game: Warhammer Quest [Average Rating:7.42 Overall Rank:353
 Our rating:           Addictive?  Long Term Replayability:  Skill Factor: Low. Modes: Co-op Players: 1-4 With a couple: You need to play 2 characters each. Play Time: 1.5-2 hours for a single game. Much longer for a campaign. Difficulty: It's probabaly impossible to get through a normal campaign with normal rules. On a per quest basis, anywhere from ridiculously easy to impossible depending on luck of the dice and level of the heroes. Individual/Group Play: Not enough skill to matter.
Mini-Review It's horribly designed. It's clunky as hell. It doesn't seem to know women even exist. It has no idea what balance is. It rewards dumb tricks while lacking any skill in most areas. Key components are practically unusable out of the box. It has stats you never use. And if you like dungeon crawl games at all, and get the chance to buy it at anything approaching a reasonable price, you should grab it. Warhammer Quest is a campaign oriented dungeon crawl adventure. Take a party of heroes and venture into a randomly generated dungeon. There's almost no plot. Place random tiles, fight the monsters that appear. There's not much maneuvering. The monsters pop up, you roll dice to bop them. Why the heck was this game so incredibly addictive? The campaign was definetly a major piece. The game is designed around leveling up heroes, which gives you better stats and (one of our favorite part) a variety of randomly rolled skills. It even has extensive rolls rules for what happens to you in between the dungeon, which consists of rolling on a big table each day in a town to find out what unpleasant event (or occasionally handy opportunity) befell you that day. The base game comes with 5 characters (one with no mini, just rules), which is really not enough for long term play. GW made a ton of extra minis however, and many fans have added even more. We put tons of effort into making the components more playable. We made monster cards for the entire book worth of monsters so we wouldn't have to look up their stats in the hard-to-use table. We made cards for all the treasures in the book to replace the table. We made reference cards for all the monster spells. We made cards for all the PC Wizard spells. We added damage counters and a variety of effect markers. We also added tons of houserules, pretty much rewriting all the traveling and event tables. We made dozens of custom characters, and played them all heavily. And yet we enjoyed the game every step of the way. I doubt I'd have the time to put that much effort into a game these days; the downside of being an adult and no longer a college student! And we don't play it much anymore; even with this much variety, we burned out eventually (HUNDREDS of plays later), and the mechanics look awfully clunky compared to modern games. But there's no denying that we got an enormous amount of fun out of this game.
Get if for: * A game that can keep you busy for a very, very long time. * Extensive campaign play. * Silly monster bashing. * Random loot and skill gathering.
Avoid it if: * You have even the slightest, tiniest, smallest aversion to dice. * You don't have tons of time to put into improving the game. * You want a well balanced, elegantly designed system. * You mind playing with innaccurate miniatures. (Ignore this if you have a fortune to spend or if you already own the world's biggest fantasy GW collection). * You don't have a fortune to spend.  58. Board Game: Witch of Salem [Average Rating:6.71 Overall Rank:901
评分:           上瘾度  长期可重玩性:  策略因素: - 模式: 合作 2人:不错 个人/小组游戏: 混合 基本信息:2-4人,30~45分钟,难度高 简评:大门、恶魔,常见的主题。机制优雅抽象。速度快,不是一手牌。 你可以得到:很好的恶魔恐惧气氛;简单快速推进;一次次的打败敌人 无视,如果你:介意被诅咒;喜欢大量的文字和规则细节
59. Board Game: Wok Star [Average Rating:7.15 Overall Rank:1162
 评分:          上瘾度  长期可重玩性: 平均 策略因素: Skill really helps, but the dice can mess you up in a major way. 模式: 合作 2人:不太好 个人/小组游戏: 鼓励个人 基本信息:2-4人,20~60分钟,3个难度等级 简评:在中餐馆做菜。每回合初掷骰子,根据点数获取食材来做菜。 你可以得到:快速疯狂的实时交互;巧妙地资源管理,提高自己的生意 无视,如果你:不喜欢实时;只喜欢2人游戏;喜欢深度策略
60. Board Game: Yggdrasil [Average Rating:7.19 Overall Rank:352]
 评分:           上瘾度  长期可重玩性: 策略因素:  模式: 合作、单人 2人:不错 个人/小组游戏: 鼓励小组 基本信息:1-6人,60~90分钟,难度变化大 简评:挪威传说主题。选择行动的游戏。 你可以得到:谜题一样的挑战,高度伸缩;主题和美工好;1~6人都合适 无视,如果你:不喜欢管理配件;介意在游戏结束前就知道自己已经赢了
61. Board Game: Zombicide [Average Rating:7.79 Overall Rank:115
 评分:           上瘾度 - Avg - 长期可重玩性:  策略因素: 适中 模式: 合作 2人:每人操纵3家 个人/小组游戏: 鼓励小组 基本信息:1-6人,60~120分钟,难度随剧本变化 简评:僵尸主题。杀僵尸,逃离险境。运气成分大,也有不少策略。 你可以得到:大杀四方的行动;多个剧本;海量模型 无视,如果你:不喜欢奇怪的规则;喜欢不同的角色;不喜欢用反直觉和反主题的策略
|